Frontier Utilities vs Payless Power

Overview

Does it even matter?

Same wires. Same grid. Same electrons. Both companies let you skip the credit check and deposit. But here’s where they differ: focus.

Here’s what separates them: Payless Power has done prepaid for 20 years. That’s all they do. 4.8-star customer ratings prove they’re good at it.

Frontier is owned by a $30 billion British company and offers everything—prepaid, fixed-rate, variable, green energy. Prepaid is one option among many.

The real question: Do you need a prepaid specialist or a company you might upgrade with later? Payless does one thing extremely well. Frontier gives you flexibility to switch to traditional billing without changing providers.

The Prepaid Comparison

Both companies offer no-credit-check, no-deposit prepaid electricity. But there are differences.

Payless Power’s approach:

• $40 to start service
• Daily balance alerts via text/email
• Add funds anytime through app, phone, or retail locations
• 20 years perfecting the prepaid model
• 4.8-star customer rating—exceptional for a budget provider

Frontier’s approach:

• Part of their broader offering
• Daily usage texts for prepaid customers
• Can upgrade to fixed-rate if credit improves
• Backed by international corporate resources
• Customer ratings are mixed overall

Payless has made prepaid their identity. Frontier treats it as one option.

Pricing Reality

Both are budget providers, but prepaid rates are typically higher than traditional plans.

Expect to pay 15-25% more per kWh with prepaid compared to a standard fixed-rate plan. On a $150 monthly bill, that’s $20-$35 extra for the no-credit-check convenience.

Between these two, rates are competitive. Check current offers—they fluctuate.

The Green Energy Question

If renewable energy matters, Frontier wins by default.

Frontier offers 100% renewable energy plans. You can choose green prepaid or green fixed-rate.

Payless has no green energy options. They focus on affordability and accessibility, not environmental features.

This is a real differentiator if sustainability matters to you.

Customer Service

Payless has surprisingly good service for a prepaid company.

Payless Power:

• 4.8-star customer rating—one of the highest in Texas
• Bilingual support (English/Spanish)
• 30-day satisfaction guarantee
• Texas-based customer service team
• Business hours only—no 24/7

Frontier:

• More mixed reviews overall
• Phone support with potential hold times (20-30 minutes)
• Functional but dated website
• Prepaid customers get daily usage texts

If customer experience matters, Payless has the edge here.

Company Stability

Frontier is owned by Centrica plc—a massive British energy company that also owns British Gas. Fortune 500-level resources. Not going anywhere.

Payless is independent. They’ve been around 20 years and survived market changes, but they don’t have corporate backing.

For most people, this doesn’t matter day-to-day. But if company stability concerns you, Frontier has deeper pockets.

Flexibility to Upgrade

Here’s where Frontier has an advantage:

If your credit improves and you want to switch to traditional billing, Frontier lets you stay with the same company. Just upgrade from prepaid to fixed-rate.

With Payless, you’d need to switch providers entirely. Their fixed-rate plans exist but still don’t require credit checks—they’re really a prepaid company at heart.

The Verdict

Payless for prepaid excellence. Frontier for flexibility and options.

Choose Payless Power if:

• Prepaid is your preferred model, not just a necessity
• Customer service quality matters—their ratings are excellent
• You like daily balance alerts and the pay-as-you-go approach
• Green energy isn’t a priority

Choose Frontier if:

• You want prepaid now but might switch to fixed-rate later
• Green energy options matter to you
• You prefer a company backed by a major corporation
• You want all your options under one roof

The honest take: If you need prepaid because of credit issues, both work. Payless does prepaid better—it’s all they do. But Frontier gives you a path to traditional billing without switching companies. That flexibility has value if your situation might change.

Related Pages

Company Profiles

• Frontier Utilities
• Payless Power

Best-For Categories

• Best Prepaid Electricity — Payless and Frontier both rank among top prepaid options
• Best No-Deposit Electricity — Both offer no-deposit service
• Best for Bad Credit — Prepaid options for credit-challenged customers
• Best Same-Day Service — Both offer same-day connections

Related Comparisons

• Frontier vs 4Change
• Frontier vs Discount Power
• Payless Power vs Pulse Power
• TXU vs Payless Power