Amigo Energy vs Pennywise Power
Quick Verdict
Only Amigo Energy sells green plans. But "green" in Texas is mostly accounting—same electrons either way.
If the green marketing matters to you, you know your answer. Otherwise, compare prices on ComparePower.
Green Energy Gap
Amigo Energy sells "green" plans. Pennywise Power doesn't. But "green" in Texas is mostly accounting—same electrons either way.
What Actually Differs
Amigo Energy and Pennywise Power deliver the exact same electricity through the exact same wires. The electrons don't care whose logo is on your bill. What differs: the price, the service when something goes wrong, and the fine print in contracts.
Who's Behind These Companies
Amigo Energy: Owned by IGS Energy (via Just Energy Group Inc.). 23 years in Texas—they've survived enough grid crises to prove they won't fold mid-contract. Based in Houston, Texas.
Pennywise Power: Owned by NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG). 18 years in Texas—that track record matters when you're signing a multi-year contract. Based in Houston, Texas.
What They Actually Sell
Amigo Energy offers fixed-rate, free-nights, free-weekends, green. They sell "green" plans (mostly accounting—same electrons, but they buy renewable credits).
Pennywise Power offers fixed-rate, variable-rate.
The Money Part
Amigo Energy: Deposit depends on credit—expect $200-400 if your score is below 600.
Pennywise Power: Deposit depends on credit—expect $200-400 if your score is below 600.
The Honest Answer
Both are legitimate. Neither is a scam. The electricity is identical. What matters is: (1) who's cheaper for your actual usage, (2) whether you need to skip a credit check, and (3) if you care about green marketing. Scroll down to "The Verdict" for the quick answer. For actual rates, check ComparePower. Takes 2 minutes.
See how they compare on price
Enter your ZIP code. Real plans, real prices — takes 30 seconds.
Category Breakdown
23 years vs 18—5+ more grid crises survived
Only Amigo Energy sells green plans (it's mostly accounting, but it's something)
Rates change constantly. Check ComparePower with your actual usage.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Amigo Energy | Pennywise Power |
|---|---|---|
| Parent Company | IGS Energy (via Just Energy Group Inc.) | NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG) |
| Years in Texas | 23+ | 18+ |
| Headquarters | Houston, Texas | Houston, Texas |
| Fixed-Rate Plans | ||
| Variable Plans | ||
| Prepaid Options | ||
| Green Energy | ||
| Free Nights/Weekends | ||
| Deposit Required | Conditional | Conditional |
| Credit Check |
Trust & Complaint Data ▼
Trust & Reputation
External ratings comparison
Trust Score is a weighted average: Google (40%), BBB (35%), Trustpilot (25%)
Complaint Comparison
PUCT Data • Jul-Dec 2025
Amigo Energy
Pennywise Power
Pennywise Power has 1.2 fewer complaints per 10k customers
The Verdict
- You want green energy (it's mostly accounting, but Pennywise Power doesn't even offer that)
- You use power at night (pool pump, EV charging, night owl habits)
- You need month-to-month—Amigo Energy locks you in for 12 months minimum
- Historical reference only--Pennywise Power no longer enrolls new customers
Done researching? See actual rates.
Amigo Energy or Pennywise Power — find out which one is cheaper at your address.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: When should I choose Amigo Energy over Pennywise Power? ▼
You want green energy (it's mostly accounting, but Pennywise Power doesn't even offer that). You use power at night (pool pump, EV charging, night owl habits).
Q: When should I choose Pennywise Power over Amigo Energy? ▼
You need month-to-month—Amigo Energy locks you in for 12 months minimum. Historical reference only--Pennywise Power no longer enrolls new customers.
Q: What is the main difference between Amigo Energy and Pennywise Power? ▼
Amigo Energy leads in track record, green energy. Both companies deliver the same electricity through the same grid—the real differences are in pricing, service quality, and available plan types.
Q: Is Amigo Energy or Pennywise Power cheaper? ▼
Anyone who answers this without knowing your zip code and usage is lying. The "advertised rate" is calculated at exactly 1,000 kWh—use 800 or 1,200 and the math changes completely. Both companies exploit this. Check ComparePower with your actual usage. Takes 2 minutes, and you'll see real numbers instead of marketing.
Q: Which company has been in Texas longer, Amigo Energy or Pennywise Power? ▼
Amigo Energy: 23 years. Pennywise Power: 18 years. Similar track records. Both have survived enough Texas summers to prove they won't fold mid-contract.
Q: Which is better for green energy, Amigo Energy or Pennywise Power? ▼
Amigo Energy sells "green" plans. Pennywise Power doesn't. But here's what they don't tell you: "green" electricity in Texas is mostly accounting. They buy renewable energy credits to match your usage—the actual electrons flowing to your house are the same mix as everyone else. If the green marketing matters to you, Amigo Energy is your only option here. If you want actual environmental impact, check if they have renewable generation backing or just paper credits.
Q: What types of plans do Amigo Energy and Pennywise Power offer? ▼
Amigo Energy: fixed-rate, free-nights, free-weekends, green. Pennywise Power: fixed-rate, variable-rate. Amigo Energy has more options (4 plan types vs 2). More options = more ways to optimize, but also more ways to pick wrong. If you just want simple fixed-rate power, ignore the complexity. If you have specific needs (EV charging at night, pool pump, work-from-home AC), the right specialty plan can save you $50/month.
Q: Which is better overall, Amigo Energy or Pennywise Power? ▼
Same grid. Same wires. Same electrons. The electricity is literally identical—the only differences are price, service, and plan options. Amigo Energy wins if you prefer spanish-language customer service--real bilingual reps, not a translated faq. Pennywise Power wins if historical reference only--pennywise power no longer enrolls new customers. For everyone else? Whoever's cheaper for your usage right now. Check ComparePower—it takes 2 minutes.
More Head-to-Head Matchups
See who wins when Amigo Energy and Pennywise Power face other competitors.
Featured In Best-Of Lists
See where Amigo Energy and Pennywise Power are featured in our category guides.